Compare/John Deere 4230 vs John Deere 5101E

John Deere 4230 vs John Deere 5101E

Verdict: John Deere 4230 vs John Deere 5101E

The John Deere 4230 and the John Deere 5101E are both tractors — here is how they stack up on the figures that matter. John Deere 5101E leads on rated power with 101 hp against 100 hp. John Deere 5101E is the lighter machine (3,320 kg vs 8,100 kg), which helps on soft ground and transport, while the heavier model carries more ballast for traction-limited draft work. John Deere 5101E is the newer design (2008 vs 1973). In short: choose the John Deere 5101E for outright pulling power, or the John Deere 4230 if a tighter budget and lighter footprint matter more. Compare the full spec tables below before booking a demo.

Tune the fit score

Tell us about your operation

Acreage600 acBudgetMain crop / use

Fit & specs

John Deere

Fit score

Best match

Clear

John Deere

Fit score

Best match

Clear

Rated power

100 hp

101 hp

Confidence

98%

Guide price

—

Overview

Manufacturer

John DeereReference

Optional creeper range adds additional speeds to the first five gears of the Syncro-Range transmission. An interlock prevents shifting into gears 6 through 8 while the creeper is engaged.Reference

With 16.9-30 rear tires.Reference

Total built

90 (Low-Profile)Reference

—

Drive

4x4 HFWD 4WDReference

—

Final drives

planetaryReference

Differential lock

hydro-mechanical rearReference

rear standardReference

Original price

—

$48,135 (2011)Reference

Steering

—

hydrostatic powerReference

Variants

4230

row-cropReference

—

4230 Hi-Crop

high clearanceReference

—

4230 LP

low-profileReference

—

5101E

—

utility chassisReference

5101EN

—

narrow chassisReference

Engine

Drawbar (tested)

62.6 kWReference

—

Displacement

5.9 LReference

4.5 LReference

Bore/Stroke

108 x 108 mmReference

106 x 127 mmReference

Air cleaner

dry with secondary elementReference

dryReference

Pre-heating

coolant heaterReference

—

Compression

16.2:1Reference

17.6:1Reference

Rated RPM

2200Reference

2400Reference

Idle RPM

800-2400Reference

825-2625Reference

Operating RPM

1500-2200Reference

—

Firing order

1-5-3-6-2-4Reference

1-3-4-2Reference

Starter

electricReference

—

Starter volts

12Reference

Oil capacity

58.7 LReference

43.5 LReference

Coolant capacity

22.7 LReference

11.4 LReference

Power at rated engine speed

74.8 kWReference

61.8 kWReference

Max power

62.6 kWReference

62.5 kWReference

Fuel Type

DieselReference

dieselReference

No of Cylinders

6-cylinder | 6-cylinderReference

4 cylinderReference

Rated engine speed

2,200 | 1,500-2,200 RPMReference

2,400 RPMReference

Bore and stroke

4.25x4.75 inchesReference

4.19x5.00 inchesReference

Compression ratio

16.2:1Reference

17.6:1Reference

Cooling system

liquid-cooled inline horizontal-shaft | 24 qtsReference

liquid-cooledReference

Engine (gross)

—

75.3 kWReference

Emissions

—

Tier 2Reference

Rated Power (gross)

—

75.3 kWReference

Fuel system

—

direct injectionReference

Intake valve clearance

—

0.356 mmReference

Exhaust valve clearance

—

0.457 mmReference

Emissions compliance

—

Tier 3Reference

Transmission

Syncro-Range CreeperReference

PowrReverserReference

Gears

13 forward and 4 reverseReference

12 forward and reverseReference

Clutch

hydraulic wet discsReference

wet discReference

Rear Axle Drive Type

planetaryReference

Transmission Type

—

Power ShuttleReference

forward and reverse options

—

PowrReverser : partially synchronized: 12 F and 12 RReference

Wheel Drive

—

4 WDReference

PTO & Hydraulics

PTO (claimed)

74.6 kWReference

61.1 kWReference

PTO (tested)

74.8 kWReference

62.5 kWReference

Hydraulic system

60.6 LReference

—

Type

creeperReference

partially synchronizedReference

Capacity

60.6 LReference

276 ciReference

Valves

1 to 3Reference

—

Rear Type

IIReference

2/1Reference

Rear PTO

independentReference

Rear PTO Type

540/1000 (1.375)Reference

540/1000 (optional)Reference

Pressure

—

195.0 barReference

Rear valves

—

1 to 3Reference

Mid valves

—

2 (optional)Reference

Pump flow

—

60.2 lpmReference

Total flow

—

85.2 lpmReference

Steering flow

—

25.0 lpmReference

Steering press.

—

131.0 barReference

Control

—

position control and top-link draft sensingReference

Rear lift (at 24"/610mm)

—

1457 kgReference

Capacities

Fuel

140.0 LReference

126.8 LReference

Front hubs

—

0.7 LReference

Front diff.

—

4.5 LReference

Fuel tank

—

126.8 LReference

Crankcase oil volume

—

9 qtsReference

Dimensions

Wheelbase

264 cmReference

217 cmReference

Weight

8100 to 10800 poundsReference

3320 kgReference

Front tire

9.5L-15Reference

12.4-24Reference

Rear tire

18.4-34Reference

18.4-30Reference

Ag front

12.4-24Reference

Ag rear

18.4-38Reference

18.4-30Reference

2WD Length

420 cmReference

—

4WD Length

430 cmReference

—

Width

138 cmReference

164 cmReference

Rack-and-pinion rear axle

86 by 2870 mmReference

—

Front tread

147 to 243 cmReference

—

Rear tread

154 to 299 cmReference

—

Shipping

3855 kgReference

—

Operating

4898 kgReference

—

Ballasted

6418 kgReference

—

Steering wheel

220 cmReference

—

Industrial front

—

12.5/80-18Reference

Industrial rear

—

19.5L-24Reference

Length

—

374 cmReference

Height (hood)

—

137 cmReference

Height (cab)

—

250 cmReference

Operating weight

—

3320 kgReference

Clearance (front axle)

—

41 cmReference

John Deere 4230 attachments

4230 Serial Number Location

4230 Serial Numbers

1973

1000Reference

—

1974

13000Reference

—

1975

22074Reference

—

1976

28957Reference

—

1977

35588Reference

—

Final

42331Reference

—

Electrical

Ground

negativeReference

Charging system

alternatorReference

Batteries

2Reference

—

Battery volts

6Reference

12Reference

Battery options

2 | 2Reference

—

Charging amps

—

120 (optional)Reference

Battery CCA

—

950Reference

Total cold cranking amps

—

750 ampsReference

Attachment overview

John Deere 4230 Height

Cab

279 cmReference

—

Exhaust

385 cmReference

—

Test results

Fuel use

26.5 l/hourReference

21.2 l/hourReference

Max pull

5057 kgReference

—

Speeds

General

Make & Model

John DeereReference

SCV control

—

JoystickReference

Rear Axle Type

—

FlangeReference

Country of manufacturer

—

USAReference

PTO

Rear PTO Power

AvailableReference

PTO Power

—

86 hpReference

Rear PTO RPM

—

540 RPMReference

Hydraulics

Hydraulics Type

closed centerReference

open centerReference

Remote Valves

1 to 3Reference

2 or 3Reference

Rear Hitch category (SAE designation)

Category IIReference

Category 2/1Reference

Pump Rated Output (total)

—

22.5 gpmReference

Maximum operating pressure

—

2,828 psiReference

Steering & Implements flow

—

6.6 gpm (15.9 gpm)Reference

Rear Hitch Sensing Type

—

position control and top-link draft sensingReference

Dimensions & weight

Overall Width

227.6 cmReference

164.1 cmReference

Height Over Cab

—

253.2 cmReference

Overall Length

—

374.9 cmReference

Front axle clearance

—

38.6 cmReference

Overall weight

—

3,320.3 kgReference

Wheels & tyres

Front Wheel tread range

9.5L-15, 7.5L-15, 7.50-16, 11.00-12, 7.50-18, 10.00-16, 12.4-24Reference

—

Rear Wheel Type

—

Ag rear:18.4-30 | Industrial rear:19.5L-24Reference

Front Wheel Type

—

Ag front:12.4-24 | Industrial front:2.5/80-18Reference

John Deere 5101E attachments

5101E Serial Numbers

Location:

—

Left side of tractor above front axle.Reference

Steering & brakes

Brakes

—

independent hydraulic wet discReference

Steering type

—

Hydrostatic PowerReference

Operator station

Cab Availability

—

AvailableReference

Seat Suspension

—

TrueReference

Fit score weighs budget, operation size, crop match and data confidence against the details above. It’s guidance, not advice — always confirm with a dealer demo.