John Deere S170 vs John Deere X584
Verdict: John Deere S170 vs John Deere X584
The John Deere S170 and the John Deere X584 are both lawn tractors — here is how they stack up on the figures that matter. Both are rated at the same 24 hp. John Deere S170 is the lighter machine (228 kg vs 314 kg), which helps on soft ground and transport, while the heavier model carries more ballast for traction-limited draft work. John Deere X584 holds more fuel (16.7 L vs 9.1 L) for longer stints between fills. John Deere S170 is the newer design (2021 vs 2016). Use the full side-by-side spec tables below to weigh the details against your own operation, and confirm with a dealer demo.
Fit score weighs budget, operation size, crop match and data confidence against the details above. It’s guidance, not advice — always confirm with a dealer demo.